HOA Won't Allow Homes To Be Rented To Homosexuals, Unmarried Couples

An East Orange County subdivision is facing a dilemma. Several residents say the Homeowner's Association at the Rybolt Reserve subdivision in Orange County is discriminating against renters.

"The Homeowner's Association is totally out of control," said Suzane Musashe of Jander Property Management.

Musashe leases homes for investors in Rybolts Reserve. She said the association is refusing to rent to gay couples or other adults who are not married.

"I feel like I am back in the 60's because there is such discrimination going on," said Musashe.

The rental rules are clearly laid out in the HOA resolution. It says Rybolts Reserve is a family oriented community and the board seeks to preserve the character of the community.

"I really believe they are prejudice against renters clear as day. There is no reason for it," said Robert Hapka.

Hapka has been renting a home in Rybolts Reserve for three years. He is married but says the HOA is trying to push him out, as well, by refusing to give renters bar codes for their cars so they can get through the gate easily.

He said all renters were taken out of the call box and locked out of the subdivision.

"It's ridiculous," Hapka said.

He cannot believe the HOA is allowed to treat him this way and discriminate against other renters who are not married.

Musahse said the strict rules are so limiting, they will send some homeowners into foreclosure.

"You can only rent to a married couple, that's it. That eliminates more than half your market," Musahse added.

Orlando does have a law that protects same sex couples who buy a home. Commissioner Bill Segal said he is looking into the issue further to see if the county should adopt an ordinance that protects same sex renters, too.

The HOA president and neighborhood attorney declined to comment.