Local

Panel says controversial Seminole County textbook is appropriate for classroom

SEMINOLE COUNTY, Fla. — A history book has stirred so much controversy in Seminole County that school county brought in a panel of experts to determine whether to keep it next year.
 
9 Investigates first reported in February on some parents' concerns about the book that they said teaches students the pillars of Islam and even some Islamic prayers.
 
Only three people showed up to speak during the public comment portion of the meeting, but all three spoke out against the book. That was after a panel of eight experts went line by line through the reasons they believe the book is appropriate for 10th grader students.
 
"As far as accuracy and appropriateness for this grade level, I found it appropriate and accurate," Richard Cologne of Lake Mary High School said about the text.
 
"I think it's extremely objective and I have no issues with the accuracy of this textbook," Brad Barcelo of Crooms Academy said.

Raw: Dad discusses thoughts on Islamic lessons (prior to panel's decision)

Raw: Full interview with school district (prior to panel's decision) 

The section in question involves the religion of Islam. Some parents argued that the text goes too far by including a prayer written on the black flag of ISIS.
 
"Our concern is this is a violation of the Establishment Clause, the fact that these children had to say an Islamic prayer," parent Lisa Houston said.
 
But others said the book shouldn't be used because they believe it's too vague and should include more details about all religions. They said that would make the history book more accurate.
 
"We need to be truthful about what's going on with all the religions being taught there are good points and bad points," parent Maureen Miller said.
 
The goal of the panel was to determine if the book fits state standards. They determined that it is appropriate.
 
"It covers everything these students are supposed to know, based on the benchmarks," Matt Vernon of Seminole High School said.
 
The panel will put together a synopsis to be sent to the superintendent of schools, who will make the final decision on the fate of the book.