Central Florida woman wins nearly $1 million verdict against Orlando hotel

ORANGE COUNTY, Fla. — An Orange County jury awarded a Polk County woman a $923,000 verdict for injuries she suffered in a 2018 fall outside the Caribe Royale resort in Orlando.

On June 12, 2018, 52-year-old Melissa Allen, was walking toward the resort’s entrance when an improperly secured irrigation box cover gave way that caused causing her to fall into a knee-deep hole.


The fall caused severe joint dysfunction which required four surgeries.

According to a new release, during the five-day trial attorneys for Caribe Royale blamed Allen for the fall.

Read: Parts of Cuba are now under hurricane warning, Central Florida remains in Ian’s path

In the end, jurors found Caribe Royale responsible for Allen’s injuries and ordered them to pay $923,000 to cover her medical expenses and pain and suffering.

“Property owners have an imperative duty to keep their grounds free from hazards like the one that caused life-altering injuries to our client,” attorney Varun Ramnarine said. “We’re pleased that the jury vindicated Ms. Allen and saw that this fall - and the recurring pain, multiple surgeries, and mental anguish it caused her - were not her fault. My team and I are pleased we obtained a just result for Mrs. Allen, and we hope it sends a message to property owners throughout Florida that negligent groundskeeping has severe consequences.”

Read: Gov. DeSantis gives updates on Florida’s emergency response to Ian

In March, an Orange County jury awarded a Clay County woman Melissa Allen after she was injured in a different incident at the Caribe Royale in 2016.

Read: Second rower dies after lightning strike, Orlando rowing club says

Click here to download the free WFTV news and weather apps, click here to download the WFTV Now app for your smart TV and click here to stream Channel 9 Eyewitness News live.

Comments on this article