9 Investigates

Florida homeowner’s insurance market in free fall as costs climb and benefits sink

ORLANDO, Fla. — Skyrocketing premiums, companies going belly-up and people across the area caught in the middle are signs of the state’s homeowner’s insurance market entering what some have called a free fall.

For the past year, Florida’s housing market had been going in only one direction – up.

WATCH: Rollins College fires long-time tenured professor accused of sexual harassing students

But home prices aren’t the only thing increasing across the state.


“We just received a notice that it was increasing by about $200,” said homeowner Chuck O’Neal about his insurance premium.

O’Neal, like so many other Floridians, is facing an insurance premium increase of 25% – and he’s one of the lucky ones.

Some residents are getting letters including a notice of non-renewal, while others are watching their insurance carriers go out of business.

WATCH: Police confiscate more than 150 guns in downtown crime enforcement operations

In February, Orlando-based St. John’s, the eighth-largest homeowner’s insurance carrier in the state, was declared insolvent.

Days later, Tampa-based Avatar lost its financial rating and is now headed in the same direction.

Meanwhile, Citizens Property Insurance, the state-backed “insurer of last resort,” has been forced to take on thousands more polices, seeing its numbers jump by about 5,000 new policies a week.

Nancy Dominguez is the managing director of the Florida Association of Public Insurance Adjusters. She notes not only are policies becoming more expensive, but many companies are also trimming back or capping benefits.

WATCH: Attorney expects more lawsuits to be filed about property appraisals following pandemic

“Most policyholders won’t find out about it until they have a claim,” Dominguez said.

So, what is the state doing about this? Not much.

A Senate plan to reduce roof claims and limit costly litigation died, leaving homeowners across the state facing rising costs, lower benefits and the hopes that their carrier stays in business.

Click here to download the free WFTV news and weather apps, and click here to watch the latest news on your Smart TV.