Suspects in fatal stabbing on USF campus arrested in Ocala

OCALA, Fla. — Two men accused of taking part in a fatal stabbing on the University of South Florida campus in Tampa have been arrested in Central Florida.


Officers from the USF Police Department responded to reports of a dead person in a parking lot near the Fine Arts Building early Saturday morning.

They arrived to find a man identified as 61-year-old Winton Cutchins of Tampa dead with obvious signs of trauma to his upper body.

READ: Michelle Parker: Nothing found in search related to case of missing woman

Just four hours later, at approximately noon, 20-year-old David Tyler Bartles and 35-year-old Thomas Allen Phanphilathip were taken into custody in connection with Cutchins’ death.

According to investigators, Bartles and Phanphilathip arrived at Cuthins’ home early Saturday morning and asked for a ride to a bus depot.

Police say Cutchins agreed and drove them to a parking lot on the USF campus at around 6:30 a.m. That’s when investigators say they believe Bartles and Phanphilathip began their “targeted” attack on Cutchins with a knife.

Police say the two suspects removed Cutchins from his pickup truck and drove off with it, leaving him in the parking lot.

READ: Orlando Museum of Art sues former director accusing him of trying to profit off fake Basquiat art

USF police transmitted a description of Cutchins’ older model Chevrolet pickup truck to nearby law enforcement agencies, believing the murder suspects were still in possession of it.

Officers with the Ocala Police Department made contact with the two suspects around noon Saturday at a local gas station after they were reported as “looking suspicious.”

The Ocala police officers were eventually alerted by USF police that Bartles and Phanphilathip were suspects in a murder and took them into custody.

The suspects were still in possession of Cutchins’ truck, as investigators presumed.

READ: Osceola County woman arrested for attempted murder at hotel, deputies say

Both Bartles and Phanphilathip are being held in the Marion County jail awaiting extradition back to Tampa on charges of first-degree murder and theft of a motor vehicle by force.

According to USF police, neither Bartles, Phanphilathip, nor Cutchins are affiliated with the university in any way and there was never a safety risk to the overall USF community.

Click here to download the free WFTV news and weather apps, click here to download the WFTV Now app for your smart TV and click here to stream Channel 9 Eyewitness News live.